The idea of putting cameras in classrooms usually sparks a heated debate about privacy and trust. However, Celeste Hedequist approaches the subject from a behavioral science perspective in her new policy proposal. She argues that we are overlooking a powerful psychological tool: the Hawthorne Effect. This phenomenon refers to the tendency of individuals to improve their behavior and performance simply because they know they are being observed.
In her proposal, Hedequist suggests that the strategic use of surveillance—specifically “surveillance of leadership”—could be the key to breaking cycles of classroom aggression. Currently, many classrooms are “black boxes.” Parents and administrators only know what happens after a serious incident occurs. This lack of transparency allows toxic dynamics, such as teacher bias or chronic unaddressed bullying, to persist for months.
Celeste Hedequist proposes that when a teacher receives poor “upward reviews” from students or when a classroom shows high rates of aggression, cameras should be introduced not as a punitive measure, but as a corrective one. The presence of a monitor changes the dynamic of the room. It encourages the leader to be on their “best behavior,” employing the de-escalation strategies and patience that might otherwise slip during a stressful day.
Hedequist acknowledges the challenge: “Arguably, it will be challenged by some as unfair.” Yet, she counters that if there is unfairness in a classroom, the burden should fall on the leadership to fix it. The goal is to motivate good leaders to strive for consistency. Once a teacher sees that a calm, fair, and observed environment leads to better student behavior, the positive changes can become habituated.
By leveraging the Hawthorne Effect, schools can create a culture of transparency where best practices aren’t just taught in a seminar once a year, but are practiced daily under the supportive eye of the community. It is a bold step, but as Celeste Hedequist argues, our children deserve the highest level of competence and safety we can provide.
To read the full details of this transformative approach, you can view the complete proposal here: A New Policy Proposal for Reducing Violence & Aggression in the Classroom: A Focus on Leadership Responsibility for Outcomes
